Justin Trudeau is a Serious Candidate for a Serious Party

I agree with Andrew Coyne that the Liberal Party of Canada needs to be the party of bold policy ideas and that on some issues we need to be to the left of the NDP/to the right of the Conservatives. However, I strongly disagree with Mr. Coyne’s assertion that “a party that is preparing to throw itself at Justin Trudeau is not a serious party.” The Liberal Party needs to have a competitive leadership race with many qualified candidates. Justin Trudeau would be a serious candidate and would be a solid choice for leader of the Liberal Party, if the Liberal Party wants to be patient and pursue a long-term strategy.
Justin Trudeau and the long-game:

As Premier McGuinty outlined in his speech at the 2012 Biennial Convention, the Liberal Party needs to elect a young leader and give that leader more than one election to rebuild the party. Liberals need to burn the phrase “two election strategy” into their minds. No one seriously believes that we can form the government after one election, and we need to show Canadians that we are a humble, substantive alternative to the divisive bullies Harper and Mulcair. This will take more than one election and we need a leader who can grow with the Liberal Party. Justin Trudeau is 40 years of age as I type this. In 2015, Prime Minister Harper will be 56 (with a full head of grey hair) and Thomas Mulcair will be 61. Justin Trudeau’s youth would bring a new energy to the Liberal Party. While his name evokes a nostalgic connection to the past, the fact that he was elected in 2008 would give the Liberal Party a clean break with the sponsorship scandal. Trudeau is fluently bilingual, but the fact that he grew up in politics makes him fluent in the political language of both French and English Canada.

Trudeau does have a ways to go before he is prime minister material. He is great at giving speeches (when I saw him speak in Parkdale-High Park there was a real electricity in the air) but he needs to speak with a substance and gravity that can only come with time. His name recognition is a great strength. I would also argue that the fact that a certain (small) percentage of Canadians who have a predisposition for/against Trudeau because of his name is another advantage as that good will will bring some Canadians back in to the Liberal Party and Trudeau will get to prove those who irrationally dislike him wrong when he enters the national arena. Becoming the leader the Liberal Party needs will be a lot of work. Justin has shown his strong work ethic on a number of occasions. Running and winning (twice) in Papineau was no small feat. Trudeau has also been a loyal liberal soldier traveling the country for the party. One specific example that I believe shows his commitment was his boxing match with Senator Brazeau. Trudeau saw that he was outgunned, so he spent months training and preparing himself. This is the kind of commitment the Liberal Party needs from its next leader.

The 4 pillars of a winning political campaign:

In the past, Canadian political parties have relied on a combination of three elements to win: a strong leader, strong policy,a strong political machine and disorganized opponents. Under Jean Chretien the LPC focused on having a strong leader, a strong political machine and disorganized political opponents.

In the last few elections the Conservatives have relied on their leader, their political machine and a disorganized opposition. The NDP have gone all in with their leader in 2008/2011 and are trying to play organizational catch up while keeping the Liberals weak. In 2011 the Liberal Party tried to go all in with policy with disastrous results.

In 2015 the Liberal Party needs to have a strong, charismatic leader who campaigns with a solid machine and a solid set of unique policy proposals. We have done a great job explaining why Harper is bad, we need to do the same with Mulcair while always saying what we would do if elected.

Trudeau’s magnetism is not something that a politician can necessarily learn, as is his ability to promote progressive policies in the language of the centre-right and the values of fiscal and personal responsibility in the language of the left.

Justin Trudeau doesn’t fit into the CPC or NDP paradigm:

One distinct advantage that Mr. Trudeau has is that his reality is frustratingly foreign to the Conservatives and New Democrats.

Conservatives purged their party of the genuine grassroots energy and principled policy positions of the old Reform Party and have become solely the party of their leader, Stephen Harper. The CPC’s divisive, slash and burn politics would see an election against Justin Trudeau as the opportunity they’ve always wanted to against Justin’s father. The NDP have a different  mindset. New Democrats do not care about getting real results for Canadians, they only care about getting more NDP seats in parliament. When Jack Layton decided to betray the progressive budget that Paul Martin had negotiated with him in 2005, he did so because the NDP only had 18 seats in parliament. In the NDP worldview Jack Layton, who has no major accomplishments at the federal level, is a hero simply because he helped elect 103 NDP MPs. The NDP and CPC both seem to believe that the Liberals would try and run Justin Trudeau on his father’s accomplishments. They would both be trying to attack the Liberal Party from a perspective that would not be accessible to the majority of Canadians who aren’t as blindly ideological as the CPC and NDP.


Justin Trudeau still has to prove himself as a leader, as does any candidate running for that position. He may be the unique blend of charisma, substance and hard work that the Liberal Party needs. However, one thing he needs from Liberals is patience.

Liberals need  to stop panicking. We aren’t going to die out in one election–but we aren’t going to rise from the ashes like a phoenix, either. Every single Liberal needs to be working hard to rebuild the party. No political party can win solely on the strength of their leader.

Justin Trudeau has been thoughtful and contemplative in his approach to entering the Liberal leadership race. He is a serious candidate and should be treated as one.

4 responses to “Justin Trudeau is a Serious Candidate for a Serious Party

  1. Mr.T’s time is coming, but it is not nigh. He should sit out the next leadership race and continue to build a following as an effective Member and a scathing critic of the NDP minority government which will be the result of the next federal election. When the electorate has finally seen the folly of the trend toward polarization, a united and vocal party of the centre will begin to look attractive again. The party should also be courting Liz May with an eye to legitemizing her platform. This will help to lure votes away from the equally extremist Cons and New Dems.

    • If Trudeau shows the ability to rebuilt the Liberals into a modern party that recognizes it isn’t going to become the govt just because it usually is the govt then his time is now. The Liberal leader will not become PM in 2015. We are not electing the “next PM of Canada” anymore. We are electing the leader that will reform the Liberal Party of Canada and if JT shows himself capable of that then he looks pretty good to me.

      And I’d be more interested in a Liberal/Green merger/alliance than a Liberal/NDP one.

      Before Trudeau I said pretty much what the blog says and have been saying it since before JT’s name came up as a candidate. JT can keep the party going while it reforms better than most possible candidates and if he shows the ability to grow it as he himself grows as leader then his time is now not later.

  2. I think Justin’s main talent lies in his ability to be an attentive celebrity in social situations where the focus of attention is on Justin. I’ve never heard him say something politically or diplomatically astute ie going half way by saying the Conservatives are right about some things but ‘here’s where I draw the line…’ He just says ‘yay’ or ‘boo’ on policy as if he were talking about flavours of ice cream. Were there any statements from Justin on the 2012 budget? He is not too young or too inexperienced – just distracted and amused by his own theatrics. A woman or man who is Prime Minister material will do their homework and ponder deeply on the intricacies of issues long before they enter public life and they can not help but share their thoughts substantively on these complex issues. Justin’s areas of expertise ie even thinking it’s appropriate to do boxing and cooking up stupid ideas like cutting the looser’s hair and telling Canadians that his staff had to work very hard to find a boxing opponent makes him incredibly shallow. He isn’t going to grow out of his limited scope on why he’s on Parliament Hill. I am relieved that Justin seems to know that the Liberals will not elect him as leader. The three people who have stepped forward so far are all substantial thinkers. Justin’s cheerleadier-type speeches at fundraisers is very helpful to the Party but if his wife wants him to leave federal politics, maybe he could focus on fundraising for a reincarnation of Katamavik. I think Justin’s strongest talent is hands-on youth work perhaps on an international as well as on a nationwide basis.

  3. Enough of this Justin talk.
    Can he just come out and say he’s not running. It’ll be better for the party and better for the country.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s